Can't Believe The Sims 4 revives The Sims 3's craziest feature 11 years after I last played it

Anyone who has spent enough time with The Sims have done it. Fence life is charming. Until it isn't. Perfect marriages, pristine homes and well-adjusted children only remain interesting for so long before temptation creeps in. Then it hits them: the desire for unrestrained chaos. This isn't because players want gore for gore's sake, but because Maxi's flagship has always been at its best when it lets curiosity, impulse, and bad decisions spill out in unexpected ways.

Historically, The Sims has excelled at presenting scandal while hesitating to follow through with serious consequences. A Sim can get caught cheating. A celebrity can spiral. A public meltdown can unfold in full view of the neighborhood. But more often than not, these moments resolve quietly. Relationships cool down. Moodlet fades. Life goes on, largely unchanged. It wasn't always like that.

IN The Sims 3s Late Night EP, the consequences were not only present. They were public, systemic and often deeply uncomfortable. It took time away from the limelight, and maybe some bribery and deflection, to remove the taint from a sim. 11 years ago this was my nightmare. Often, I was publicly shamed for saving scum. And now, more than a decade later, The Sims 4 seems poised to revive that design philosophy with the return of a reworked version of Public Disgraces, now more politely renamed “Scandals,” in the upcoming Royalty & Legacy expansion pack.

Family

I've been playing The Sims for 20 years, and The Sims 4's next expansion pack feels like an answered prayer

There's always been an expansion pack I've wanted for The Sims, but after 20 years it seemed impossible. Now my dreams have come true.

The Sims 3 Public Disgrace System was brutal, and The Sims 4 brings back a version of it

Once the paparazzi followed you and caught wind of problematic behavior, it was over. Public shaming was one of The Sims 3s most quietly radical system because of its consequences. Introduced alongside the celebrity mechanic, they turned gossip into gameplay and reputation into something that actively shaped a Sim's life. Celebrities can be disgraced for a wide range of behaviors:

These events did not only trigger embarrassment. They changed how other Sims reacted, how careers progressed, and how stories unfolded. A disgraced sim can lose celebrity status, face public hostility, receive an annoying “publicly disgraced” sim mood for 72 hours, or even fight professionally. Even more strikingly, Sims can be falsely accused – forcing players to navigate defamation lawsuits to clear their names. And I learned the hard way that you can actually lose these lawsuits.

It was messy, yes, but it was also deliciously layered. Public Disgraces admitted something The Sims often goes around: private choices don't always stay private, especially when power, fame or visibility are involved.

Why public shaming and scandals worked so well

What made Public Disgraces effective was not shock value. It was continuity. Plots created narrative momentum instead of isolated moments. A single mistake can reflect on a Sim's career and social life, forcing players to respond rather than reset. That system also encouraged empathy. When my sim was falsely accused of wrongdoing, I felt genuinely offended. A sim severely punished for behavior players barely noticed highlighted the absurdity and cruelty of public scrutiny. The game did not moralize, but it reacted.

On the contrary The Sims 4 have often treated drama as cosmetic. Emotional states flare up quickly and resolve just as quickly. Reputation systems exist, and now sims have memories to permanently destroy a relationship. However, The Sims 4's long-term storytelling is very new. The result is a sandbox that looks expressive but feels strangely frictionless. Except that could change now.

Family

After 2,058 hours in The Sims 4, these 3 expansion packs are non-negotiable

I've been playing The Sims 4 for over ten years, and I think every Sim should have these three expansion packs – regardless of their playstyle.

The Royal & Legacy Expansion Pack's Scandals is a messy feature that The Sims 4 needs right now

The Royalty & Legacy Expansion Pack trailer suggests a return to form. In an extraordinary moment, a royal affair is revealed when a maid leaks the secret, sparking a scandal that ripples outward. The setting matters. This is not just interpersonal drama, but exposure, power, and consequences intersecting in a way The Sims 4 have largely avoided. Early indications are that scandals are coming:

Be triggered by witnesses and leaks, not just paparazzi.
Influence public perception, especially for royal sims.
Connect to wider systems around legacy and perhaps celebrity status.

If implemented with even a fraction of The Sims 3s depth, this mechanic can finally give incredible weight to player choices. Especially for Sims whose lives are meant to be scrutinized.

Why this is important to The Sims 4 right now

Eleven years into The Sims 4s lifespan, players no longer ask for more items or aesthetics alone. They demand systems that talk to each other. For stories that last. For consequences that complicate, rather than decorate, the gameplay. Scandals represent a philosophical shift. They suggest a willingness to allow Sims to exist in a world that responds meaningfully to them: a world where reputations can be damaged, repaired, or weaponized over time. That kind of depth is especially crucial for an expansion centered on royalty and legacy, where lineage, perception and public narrative are inseparable.

Welcome back to meaningful clutter

The return of public shaming—or scandals, by whatever name—signals something important. The Sims 4 no longer content to keep their drama safe. It's reaching back to one of the franchise's most ambitious ideas and asking what it might look like now, with more tools, more systems, and a player base hungry for friction.

Mess has always been a part of The Sims'DNA. What has been missing is the follow-up. If Royalty & Legacy delivers on part of the bet The Sims 3 once dared to do, then this is not just nostalgia resurfacing. It is the return of consequences that actually matters. And for a game built around storytelling, it might be the most exciting development yet.